Везде
WHO ACTUALLY BUILT THE LEFT BANK TSIMLYANSK SETTLEMENT
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
WHO ACTUALLY BUILT THE LEFT BANK TSIMLYANSK SETTLEMENT
Annotation
PII
S0869-60630000408-1-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Gennady Afanasiev 
Edition
Issue 3
Pages
108-119
Abstract

The article considers the origins of the architecture at Levoberezhnoye Tsimlyanskoye, which some scholars believe to be the site of Sarkel. M.I. Artamonov, P.A. Rappoport and S.A. Pletneva have put forth several arguments in favor of the assumption that it were local “Eurasian” and not Byzantine architects who had built Sarkel for the Khazars. The arguments include the following: the walls of the fortress were built without any foundations in the native soil, the bricks are not of Byzantine format, the fortress in not Byzantine in layout. The author believes that the above arguments are unfounded. Calculations show that the ground could hold the weight of the fortress even without underground foundations. The format of the bricks from Leveberezhnoye has many parallels at Byzantine sites. The author is of the opinion that Roman-Byzantine fortifi cation architecture from the 1st – 2nd cc. to the 9th c. offers analogies of the layout at Levoberezhnoye. Hence it is possible to give credence to the Byzantine sources which mention a fortress that Byzantine architects built for the Khazars by order of the Emperor Theophilus.

Date of publication
01.07.2011
Number of purchasers
1
Views
495
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

Artamonov M.I. Sarkel i nekotorye drugie ukrepleniya severo-zapadnoj Khazarii // SA. 1940. № 6.


Artamonov M.I. Sarkel – Belaya Vezha // Tr. Volgo-Donskoj arkheolog. ehkspeditsii. T. I. M.; L., 1958 (MIA; № 62).


Artamonov M.I. Ot redaktora // Tr. Volgo-Donskoj arkheolog. ehkspeditsii. T. II. M.; L., 1959 (MIA; № 75). Artamonov M.I. Istoriya khazar. L., 1962.


Afanas'ev G.E. Naselenie lesostepnoj zony bassejna Srednego Dona v VIII−X vv. (alanskij variant saltovo-mayatskoj kul'tury) // AON. Vyp. 2. M., 1987.


Afanas'ev G.E. Donskie alany. Sotsial'nye struktury alano-asso-burtasskogo naseleniya bassejna Srednego Dona. M., 1993.


Afanas'ev G.E. Gde zhe arkheologicheskie svidetel'stva suschestvovaniya khazarskogo gosudarstva? // RA. 2001. № 2.


Afanas'ev G.E. K probleme istoricheskoj interpretatsii arkheologicheskikh pamyatnikov (po povodu knigi A.A. Tortiki “Severo-Zapadnaya Khazariya v kontekste istorii Vostochnoj Evropy”) // Arkheologiya Kavkaza i Blizhnego Vostoka. M., 2008.


Afanas'ev G.E. K probleme lokalizatsii Khazarii i Furt–asii (o protivorechii dannykh arkheologii i pis'mennykh istochnikov) // Forum “Idel'–Altaj”. Kazan', 2009.


Afanas'ev G.E. O vizantijskikh linejnykh merakh v Mayatskoj kreposti // Verkhnedonskoj sb. Vyp. V. Lipetsk, 2010.


Vitruvij. Desyat' knig ob arkhitekture. M., 2006.


Dolmatov B.I. Mekhanika gruntov, osnovaniya i fundamenty. M., 1989.


Ivanov A.A. Rannesrednevekovye podkurgannye kochevnicheskie zakhoroneniya vtoroj poloviny VII – pervoj poloviny IX v. Nizhnego Dona i Volgo-Donskogo mezhdurech'ya: Avtoref. dis. … kand. ist. nauk. Volgograd, 2000.


Konstantin Bagryanorodnyj. Ob upravlenii imperiej. M., 1989.


Kruglov E.V. Nekotorye problemy analiza osobennostej obrascheniya vizantijskikh monet VI−VIII vv. v vostochnoevropejskikh stepyakh // Khazarskij al'manakh. T. 1. Khar'kov, 2002.


Kyzlasov I.L. Runicheskie pis'mennosti evrazijskikh stepej. M., 1994.


Larenok P.A., Semyonov A.I. Sarkel, Sarkel, esche Sarkel… // DA. 1999. № 3, 4.


Le Boehk Ya. Rimskaya armiya ehpokhi rannej imperii. M., 2001.


Lekvinadze V.A. Materialy po istorii i arkhitekture Apsarskoj kreposti // VV. 1961. T. 20.


Lyapushkin I.I. Pamyatniki saltovo-mayatskoj kul'tury v bassejne r. Don // Tr. Volgo-Donskoj arkheolog. ehkspeditsii. T. I. M.; L., 1958 (MIA; № 62).


Malakhov S.N. Protospafarij Ivan v kontekste vizantijsko-khazarskikh otnoshenij serediny IX v. // Tez. dokl. XVII Vseros. nauch. sessii vizantinistov. M., 2004.


Novosel'tsev A.P. Khazarskoe gosudarstvo i ego rol' v istorii Vostochnoj Evropy i Kavkaza. M., 1990.


Ousterkhaut R. Vizantijskie stroiteli. Kiev; M., 2005.


Pletnyova S.A. Ot kochevij k gorodam. M., 1967.


Pletnyova S.A. Saltovo-mayatskaya kul'tura // Stepi Evrazii v ehpokhu srednevekov'ya. M., 1981 (Arkheologiya SSSR).


Pletnyova S.A. Sarkel i “Shelkovyj put'”. Voronezh, 1996.


Pletnyova S.A. Ocherki khazarskoj arkheologii. M.; Ierusalim, 2000.


Popov Kh.I. Gde nakhodilas' khazarskaya krepost' Sarkel // Arkheologicheskie zapiski. Vyp. 4. Rostov n/D., 2005. Prodolzhatel' Feofana. Zhizneopisaniya vizantijskikh tsarej. M., 1992.


Rappoport P.A. Krepostnye sooruzheniya Sarkela // Tr. Volgo-Donskoj arkheolog. ehkspeditsii. T. II. M.; L., 1959 (MIA; № 75).


Savin A.M., Semyonov A.I. O tsentral'no-aziatskikh istokakh luka khazarskogo tipa // Voennaya arkheologiya. Oru zhie i voennoe delo v istoricheskoj i sotsial'noj perspektive. SPb., 1998.


Sakania S.M. Stroitel'naya keramika v Abkhazii v IV−IX vv. // Materialy po izucheniyu istoriko-kul'turnogo naslediya Severnogo Kavkaza. Vyp. VIII. M., 2008.


Sedov V.V. Drevnerusskaya narodnost'. M., 1999. Flavij Vegetsij Renat. Kratkoe izlozhenie voennogo dela // VDI. 1940. № 1.


Flyorov V.S. “Semikarakory” – krepost' Khazarskogo kaganata na Nizhnem Donu // RA. 2001. № 2.


Flyorova V.E. Graffiti Khazarii. M., 1997.


Јeremiћ M. Opeke Tsarichinog grada // Zbornik Radova. Nish i Vizantija. IV. Nish, 2006.


Anunbay Z., Anunbay M. Recent Work on the Land Walls of Istanbul: Tower 2 to Tower 5 // Dumbarton Oaks Papers. 2000. V. 54.


Bell G.L. Palace and Mosque at Ukhaidir. Oxford, 1914. Diehl Ch. L’Afrique Byzantine. Histoire de la Domination Byzantine en Afrique (533−709). Paris, 1896.


Howard-Johnston J. The spatial organization of the Khazar khaganate: the evidence of the Byzantine sources // Khazary. Vtoroj Mezhdunar. kollokvium. M., 2002.


Ierusalimskaja A.A. Die graber der Moščevaja Balka. München, 1996.


Kawatoko M. Archaeological Survey of the Rāya/al-Ṭür Area in 2003 // http://nippon.zaidan.info/seikabutsu/2003/ 01254/contents/0007_001.htm Obolensky D. The Byzantine Commonwealth. Eastern Europe 500−1453. L., 1971.


Ousterhout R., Anunbay Z., Anunbay M. Study and Restoration of the Zeyrek Camii in Istanbul: First Report, 1997–1998 // Dumbarton Oaks Papers. 2000. V. 54.


Parker S.T. The Legionary Fortress of el-Lejjun // The Roman Frontier in Central Jordan. Washington, D.C., 2006. (Dumbarton Oaks).


Petković S., Ružić M., Jovanović S. et al. Roman and Medieval Necropolis in Ravna near Knjaževac. Belgrade, 2005.


Pringle D. The Defence of Byzantine Africa from Justinian to the Arab Conquest (An account of the military history and archaeology of the African provinces in the sixth and seventh centuries). Oxford, 1981 (BAR; Intern. Ser. 99 (i)).


Schilbach E. Byzantinische Metrologie. München, 1970.


Türker A. The Gallipoli Castel in the Byzantine Period // Hacettepe Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Dergisi. 2006. Cilt 23. Sayi 2.


Underwood P.A. Some Principles of Measure in the Architecture of the Period of Justinian // Cahiers Archéologiques. 1948. III.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate