QUESTIONS OF LIGUR LANGUAGE. LIGURICA SUB SPECIE CELTO-LIGURICAE ET INDO-GEMANICAE
Table of contents
Share
QR
Metrics
QUESTIONS OF LIGUR LANGUAGE. LIGURICA SUB SPECIE CELTO-LIGURICAE ET INDO-GEMANICAE
Annotation
PII
S0373-658X0000392-4-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Edition
Pages
85-113
Abstract
The work examines the linguistic data of the remnants of the Ligurian language and takes the view of those researchers who saw two layers in Ligurian: non-Indo-European and Indo-European (Indo-European). For obvious reasons, this layer is the main focus. The study showed that the available data do not allow us to see in it the so-called language of the Paraceltic circle. The hypothesis about the intermediate position of Ligurian between the Italic and Celtic languages, accepted by many researchers, also does not find confirmation. However, the denial of the very fact of the existence of an Indo-European (or Indo-Europeanized) Ligurian language other than Celtic, which has become a fairly common place in the writings of many celtologists of the last decade, seems unacceptable.
Keywords
genetic classification, pre-Indo-European languages, Indo-European languages, Italic languages, Celtic languages, Ligurian language, substrate
Number of purchasers
1
Views
616
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite   Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

Budanova 1991 – V.P. Budanova. Etnonimiya plemen Zapadnoj Evropy: rubezh antichnosti i srednevekov'ya. M., 1991.
Eryomenko, SHCHukin 1992 – V.E. Eryomenko, M.B. SHCHukin. Kimvry, tevtony, kel'toskify i nekotorye voprosy hronologii rubezha srednego i pozdnego latena // M.B. SHCHukin, O.A. Gej (red.). Problemy hronologii epohi latena i rimskogo vremeni. SPb., 1992.

Zalesskij 1958 – N.N. Zalesskij. Etruski v Ligurii // Vestnik drevnej istorii. 1958. № 1.
Zelikov 2003 – M.V. Zelikov. Genitivno-relyativnye otnosheniya suffiksa -ko- v kontekste basksko-kel'tskih otnoshenij // YAzyk i kul'tura kel'tov. Materialy IX kollokviuma. SPb., 2003.
Kalygin, Korolyov 1989 – V.P. Kalygin, A.A. Korolyov. Vvedenie v kel'tskuyu filologiyu. M., 1989.
Stepanova 2000 – L.G. Stepanova. Ital'yanskaya lingvisticheskaya mysl' XIV–XVI vekov. SPb., 2000.
Suhachev 2002 – N.L. Suhachev. Teoriya stratov, yazykovoe smeshenie i «ob"yasnyayushchaya lingvistika» // N.N. Kazanskij (red.). Colloquia classica et indogermanica III. SPb., 2002.
Tohtas'ev 2005 – S.R. Tohtas'ev. Problema skifskogo yazyka v sovremennoj nauke // V. Cojocaru (ed.). Ethnic contacts and cultural exchanges North and West of the Black Sea from the Greek colonization to the Ottoman conquest. Iaşi, 2005.
Otkupshchikov 1988 – YU.V. Otkupshchikov. Dogrecheskij substrat. L., 1988.
Toporov 1978 – V.N. Toporov. Eshche raz ob i.-e. *budh- (: *bheudh-) // Etimologiya 1976. M., 1978.
Falileev 2003 – A.I. Falileev. Miscellanea onomastica // N.N. Kazanskij (otv. red.). Indoevropejskoe yazykoznanie i klassicheskaya filologiya 7. SPb., 2003.
Falileev 2006 – A.I. Falileev. Gall'sk. s, i.-e. *p i nekotorye aspekty interpretacii kontinental'nyh kel'tskih dannyh // N.N. Kazanskij (otv. red.). Indoevropejskoe yazykoznanie i klassicheskaya filologiya 10. SPb., 2006.
Falileev 2009a – A.I. Falileev. Kel'tskie lingvisticheskie ostatki yugo-vostochnoj Evropy: nekotorye rezul'taty i perspektivy issledovaniya // Acta Linguistica Petropolitana. T. 5. CH. 1. (= N.L. Suhachev (red.). Balkanskoe yazykoznanie. Itogi i perspektivy. Materialy rumynsko-russkogo simpoziuma.) CPb., 2009.
Falileev 2009b – A.I. Falileev. Γαίζατος iz Apollonii: gally na Balkanah i nekotorye voprosy kel'tskogo imennogo slovoobrazovaniya // N.N. Kazanskij (otv. red.). Indoevropejskoe yazykoznanie i klassicheskaya filologiya 13. SPb., 2009.
Falileev, v pechati – A.I. Falileev. Nekotorye voprosy lingvisticheskoj istorii Nizhnej Galatii // Acta Linguistica Petropolitana, v pechati.
SHmidt 2007 – K.-H. SHmidt. K koncepcii sravnitel'no-istoricheskogo analiza kel'tskogo slovarya // VYA. 2007. № 1.
Agostinetti 2004 – P. Agostinetti. Celti d’Italia. I. Archeologia, lingua e scrittura. Roma, 2004.
Anreiter 1997 – P. Anreiter. Breonen, Genaunen und Fokunaten. Innsbruck, 1997.
Anreiter 2001 – P. Anreiter. Die vorrömischen Namen Pannoniens. Budapest, 2001.
Azaretti 1977 – E. Azaretti. L’evoluzione dei dialetti liguri. Sanremo, 1977.
Baldi 1983 – P. Baldi. An introduction to the Indo-European languages. Carbondale, 1983.
Barruol 1999 – G. Barruol. Les peuples pré-romains du sud-est de la Gaule. Etude de géographie historique. Paris, 1999.
Bats 2003 – M. Bats. Ligyens et Salyens d’Hécatée à Strabon // Peuples et territoires en Gaule méditerranéenne. Montpellier, 2003.
Brugmann 1906 – K. Brugmann. Grundriss der vergleichenden Grammatik der indogermanischen Sprachen. Bd. II/1. Strassburg, 1906.
Cunliffe 1988 – B. Cunliffe. Greeks, Romans and Barbarians. Spheres of interaction. London, 1988.
Cuno 1873 – J.G. Cuno. Die Ligurer // Rheinisches Museum für Philologie. 1873. Bd. 28.
Curchin 2009 – L.A. Curchin. Toponymy of Lusitania: myth and reality // Lusitânia romana: entre o mito e a realidade. Cascais, 2009.
D’Arbois de Jubainville 1894 – H. D’Arbois de Jubainville. Les premiers habitants de l’Europe. V. 2. Paris, 1894.
De Bernardo Stempel 2000 – P. De Bernardo Stempel. Ptolemy’s Celtic Italy and Ireland: a linguistic analysis // Ptolemy. Towards a linguistic atlas of the earliest Celtic peace-names of Europe. Aberystwyth, 2000.
De Bernardo Stempel 2005a – P. De Bernardo Stempel. Ptolemy’s evidence for Germania Superior // New approaches to Celtic place-names in Ptolemy’s geography. Madrid, 2005.
De Bernardo Stempel 2005b – P. De Bernardo Stempel. Additions to Ptolemy’s evidence for Celtic Italy // New approaches to Celtic place-names in Ptolemy’s geography. Madrid, 2005.

De Bernardo Stempel 2006a – P. De Bernardo Stempel. From Ligury to Spain: unaccented *yo > (y)e in Narbonensic Votives (‘Gaulish’ δεκαντεμ), Hispanic coins (Iberian -(sk)en) and some theonyms // Palaeohispanica. 2006. T. 6.
De Bernardo Stempel 2006b – P. De Bernardo Stempel. Language and the historiography of Celticspeaking peoples // Celtes et Gaulois. L’archéologie face à l’histoire 1. Celtes et Gaulois dans l’Histoire, l’historiograhie et l’idéologie moderne. Glux-en-Glenne, 2006.
De Bernardo Stempel 2008a – P. De Bernardo Stempel. Linguistically Celtic ethnonyms: towards a classifi cation // Celtic and other languages in Ancient Europe. Salamanca, 2008.
De Bernardo Stempel 2008b – P. De Bernardo Stempel. Celtic settlements in the south of Germania Magna // Celtic and other languages in Ancient Europe. Salamanca, 2008.
De Bernardo Stempel 2009 – P. De Bernardo Stempel. La ricostruzione del celtico d’Italia sulla base dell’onomastica antica // L’Onomastica dell’Italia antica. Rome, 2009.
Del Lucchese, Gambari 2006 – A. Del Lucchese, F.M. Gambari. L’area alpine sud-occidentale e il mondo ligure // Celtes et Gaulois. L’Archéologie face à l’Histoire, 2. La préhistoire des Celtes. Glux-en-Glenne, 2006.
De Hoz 2005 – J. De Hoz. Ptolemy and the linguistic history of the Narbonensis // New approaches to Celtic place-names in Ptolemy’s geography. Madrid, 2005.
De Hoz 2010 – J. De Hoz. L’écriture gréco-ibérique et l’infl uence hellène sur les usages de l’écriture en Hispanie et dans le sud de la France // Grecs et indigènes de la Catalogne à la Mer Noire. Paris, 2010.
Delamarre 2006 – X. Delamarre. Gallo-Brittonica (suite: 11–21) // ZCP. Bd. 55. 2006.
Delamarre 2007 – X. Delamarre. Noms de personnes celtiques dans l’épigraphie classique. Paris, 2007.
Delamarre 2008 – X. Delamarre. ’Ηριδανος, le ‘fl euve de l’ouest’ // Études Celtiques. T. 36. 2008.
Devoto 1962 – G. Devoto. Pour l’histoire de l’indo-européanisation de l’Italie septentrionale: quelques etymologies lépontiques // Revue de philologie, de littérature, et d’histoire anciennes. T. 36. 1962.
Evans 1979 – D. Ellis Evans. Labyrinth of Continental Celtic // Proceedings of the British Academy V. 65. 1879.
Ernout, Meillet 1967 – A. Ernout, A. Meillet. Dictionnaire étymologique de la langue latine. Histoire des mots. 4-e éd. Paris, 1967.
Falileyev 2002 – A. Falileyev. [Rec.:] P. Anreiter. Die vorrömischen Namen Pannoniens // Acta Onomastica 2002. V. 43.
Falileyev 2007 – A. Falileyev. [Rec.:] P. Freeman. The Galatian language // Celtica. V. 25. 2007.
Frisk 1954–1972 – H. Frisk. Griechisches etymologisches Wörterbuch. Bd. 1–3. Heidelberg, 1954–1972.
Fruyt 2002 – M. Fruyt. Constraints and productivity in Latin nominal compounding // TPhS. V. 100. 2002.
Georgiev 1981 – V. Georgiev. Introduction to the history of the Indo-European languages. Sofi a, 1981.
Gorrochategui 2005 – J. Gorrochategui. Establishment and analysis of Celtic toponyms in Aquitania and the Pyrenees // New approaches to Celtic place names in Ptolemy’s geography. Madrid, 2005.
Hamp 1985 – E.P. Hamp. Indo-European ‘Gerste, orge, barley’ // KZ. Bd. 98. 1985.
Hirunuma 1986 – T. Hirunuma. The dialects of ancient northern Italy: their positioning and signifi cance // JIES. V. 14. 1986.
Hubschmid 1966–1967 – J. Hubschmid. Die asko-/usko- Suffi xe und das Problem des Ligurischen // Revue Internationale d’onomastique. T. 18, 19. 1966–1967.
Jullian 1908 – C. Jullian. Histoire de la Gaule. T. I. Paris, 1908.
Krahe 1936 – H. Krahe. Ligurish und Indogermanisch // Germanen und Indogermanen. Heidelberg, 1936.
Kretchmer 1905 – P. Kretchmer. Die Inschriften von Ornavasso und die ligurische Sprache // KZ. Bd. 37. 1905.
Lejeune 1971 – M. Lejeune. Lepontica. Paris, 1971.
Lejeune 1972 – M. Lejeune. Un problème de nomenclature: Lepontiens et Lépontique // Studi Etruschi. T. 40. 1972.
Lubotsky 2001 – A. Lubotsky. Refl exes of Proto-Indo-European *sk in Indo-Iranian // Incontri linguistici. T. 24. 2001.
Mallory, Adams 1997 – J.P. Mallory, D.Q. Adams. Encyclopedia of Indo-European Culture. London; Chicago, 1997.

Mariani 2003 – M. Mariani. Rifl essi di tipi composizionali indoeuropei nella toponomastica ligure di epoca antico-romana: ipotesi sul tipo a primo membro verbale reggente // Toponomastica ligure e preromana. Recco, 2003.
Markey, Mees 2003 – T. Markey, T. Mees. Prestino, patrimony and the Plinys // ZCP. Bd. 53. 2003.
Matasović 2009 – R. Matasović. Etymological dictionary of proto-Celtic. Leiden; Boston, 2009.
Mayrhofer 1986–2001 – M. Mayrhofer. Etymologisches Wörterbuch des Altindoarischen. Bd. I–II. Heidelberg, 1986–2001.
McCone 1996 – K. McCone. Towards a relative chronology of Ancient and Medieval Celtic sound change. Maynooth, 1996.
Mees 2003 – V. Mees. Stratum and shadow. A genealogy of stratigraphy theories from the Indo-European west // Language contacts in prehistory. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, 2003.
Meier-Lübke 1972 – W. Meier-Lübke. Romanisches etymologisches Wörterbuch. Heidelberg, 1972.
Mihailov 1987 – G. Mihailov. Le suffi xe -sk- en Thrace // Linguistique Balkanique. V. 30. 1987.
Morandi 2004 – A. Morandi. Celti d’Italia. T. 2. Epigrafi a e lingua dei Celti d’Italia. Roma, 2004.
Müllenhoff 1892 – K. Müllenhoff. Deutsche Altertumskunde. Bd. III. Berlin, 1892.
Olsen 1999 – B.A. Olsen. The noun in Biblical Armenian. Berlin; New York, 1999.
Olsen 2009 – B.A. Olsen. [Rec.:] J. Matzinger. Untersuchungen zum altarmenischen Nomen // Kratylos. Bd. 54. 2009.
Pape, Benseler 1911 – G. Pape, G.E. Benseler. Wörterbuch der griechischen Eigennamen. Bd. 1–3. Braunschweig, 1911.
Pelligrini 1983 – G.B. Pelligrini. Osservazione lessicali sulle lingue preromane dell’Italia superiore // Le lingue indoeuropee di frammentaria attestazione. Pisa, 1983.
Petracco Sicardi 1981 – G. Petracco Sicardi. La toponomastica preromana e romana della Liguria // G. Petracco Sicardi, R. Caprini. Toponomastica storica della Liguria. Genova, 1981.
Petracco Sicardi 1981a – G. Petracco Sicardi. Liguri e Celti nell’ Italia settenrionale // I Celti d’Italia. Pisa, 1981.
Pharies 1990 – D. Pharies. The origin and development of the Ibero-Romance -nc-/-ng- Suffi xes. Tübingen, 1990.
Philipon 1906 – E. Philipon. Provençal -enc; Italien -ingo, -engo // Romania. T. 35. 1906.
Pisani 1953 – V. Pisani. Le lingue dell’Italia antica oltre il latino. Torino, 1953.
Prosdocimi 1987 – A.L. Prosdocimi. Celti in Italia prima e dopo il V secolo a. C. // Celti ed etruschi nell’Italia centro-settentrionale dal V sec a. C. alla romanizzazione. Bologna, 1987.
Prósper 1998 – B.M. Prósper. Indogermanisches bei einem ligurischen Wort: «Ex rivo Vindupale» // BzNF. Bd. 33. 1998.
Rubat Borel 2006 – F. Rubat Borel. Nuovi dati per la storia delle lingue celtiche della Cisalpina // Celtes et Gaulois. L’Archéologie face à l’Histoire, 2. La préhistoire des Celtes. Glux-en-Glenne, 2006.
Schmidt 1983 – K.H. Schmidt. Grundlagen einer festlandkeltischen Grammatik // Le lingue indoeuropee di frammentaria attestazione. Pisa, 1983.
Sims-Williams 1998 – P. Sims-Williams. Celtomania and celtoscepticism // CMCS. V. 36. 1998.
Sims-Williams 2006 – P. Sims-Williams. Ancient Celtic place-names in Europe and Asia Minor. Oxford, 2006.
Sims-Williams 2007 – P. Sims-Williams. Common Celtic, Gallo-Brittonic and Insular Celtic // P.–Y. Lambert, G.–J. Pinault (eds). Gaulois et seltique sontinental. Genève, 2007.
Sims-Williams 2009 – P. Sims-Williams. Celto-Iranica // Exegisti monumenta. Wiesbaden, 2009.
Stokes 1873–1875 – W. Stokes. A conjectural emendation to Pliny // Revue Celtique. T. 2. 1873–1875.
Tagliavini 1972 – C. Tagliavini. Le origini delle lingue neolatine. Bologna, 1972.
Thollard 2009 – P. Thollard. La Gaule selon Strabon: du texte à l’archéologie. Paris, 2009.
Tomaschek 1884 – W. Tomaschek. Miscellen // Beiträge zur Kunde der indogermanischen Sprachen. Bd. 9. 1884.
Untermann 1989 – J. Untermann. Zu den Begriffen ‘Restsprache’ und ‘Trümmersprache’ // Germanische Rest- und Trümmersprachen. Berlin; New York, 1989.
Untermann 2006 – J. Untermann. Ligurisches // Studi linguistici in onore di Roberto Gusmani. Alessandria, 2006.
Vetter 1926 – E. Vetter. Ligures. Die Sprache der Ligurer // RE. Bd. XIII/1. 1926.
Villar, Prósper 2005 – F. Villar, B.M. Prósper. Vascos, Celtas e Indoeuropeos: Genes y Lenguas. Salamanca, 2005.
Vineis 1983 – E. Vineis (ed.). Le lingue indoeuropee di frammentaria attestazione. Pisa, 1983.
Wodtko et al. 2008 – D. Wodtko, B. Irslinger, C. Schneider. Nomina im indogermanischen Lexikon. Heidelberg, 2008.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate